All rights reserved. Couple Is Killed in Alleged $750,000 Murder-for-Hire Plot Designed to Keep Suspect's Affair Secret, Suspect Arrested and 'Charged with Murder' in Killing of Houston Teen Diamond Alvarez: Authorities, How a Camping Trip Among 4 Arizona Teens Ended in Murder, After 12-Year-Old's Murder, Police Arrest Teen and Suspect's Father, Who Allegedly Drove Son to Scene, 'Big Family, Old Money, New Drama': Inside the Powerful S.C. Family at Center of Murder Mystery, Alex Murdaugh Arrested, Charged with Insurance Fraud and Filing a False Police Report, Murder and QAnon: Inside the Case of Matthew Coleman, Accused of Killing Kids with Spear Gun, Ohio Teen Faces Murder Charge in Deadly Alleged Plot to Kill 13-Year-Old Friend's Mother, Wrong Woman Kidnapped and Killed in Alleged Love Triangle Murder-for-Hire Plot: Police, Missouri Woman Allegedly Killed Man to Frame Another Who Questioned Her Role in His Wife's Unsolved 2011 Murder, Celebrity Baker Charged in Murder-for-Hire Plot to Kill Ex-Boyfriend, Fianc Allegedly Planned Murder of Colo. "I would never hurt Maggie. The tragic story of the boat crash and Beach's death, the traumatic impact it had on a group of teenagers, and the way it spotlights the weight of the Murdaugh name in the local area make it an obvious entryway to the family's story. My dad was a loving man and was not abusive in any way.. It was a crime that "almost slipped through our fingers," Los Angeles police said--an 84-year-old . He rolled out of bed, bundled up warmly, pulled on his boots, and stepped outside with a metal pail. Defense attorney Jim Griffin, right, questions Alex Murdaugh, left, as he gives testimony during his murder trial at the Colleton County Courthouse in Walterboro, S.C., Feb. 23, 2023. According to The Independent, filming for the documentary wrapped before the trial began, so many of the explosive details that have come from the 19 days of testimony and counting are absent from the show. The docuseries devotes more than half of its airtime to telling the story of Mallory Beach, who died in 2019 aged 19 after a boat seemingly driven by a heavily intoxicated and belligerent Paul Murdaugh, also 19 at the time, crashed into a bridge, hurling her overboard into the waters where she drowned. It's hard to tell whether the show expects viewers to care about the murders because two people lost their lives, or feel that some type of karmic justice has been served. Angered by the accusations, Gibson punched Hodella in the face, then took out a pocket knife and stabbed her multiple times in the throat before driving around and dumping her body in Clarksville. Other witnesses corroborated the story that Murdaugh learned of his father's condition the same day Maggie and Paul were murdered. The DOC asked that Gibson be sentenced to 6 years in prison for his violation. After spending the day doing drugs and having sex, the pair returned to Gibson's house, where they argued over some pills. Vanore said there still remain questions to be answered in the slayings, but its certainly on our list of cases that were looking at with regard to Gibsons possible involvement. "Mahaska County, it is one of the safest counties in the state of Iowa," he told producers. [10], During his murder trial, prosecutors presented an interview Gibson had given to investigators upon his arrest, during which he claimed that an "evil" had overcome him and had made him commit the murder. Philadelphia District Attorney Larry Krasner acknowledged that police did not have enough probable cause at the time to arrest Gibson for his mothers death, but he said both the police department and his office attempted to aid the Delaware DOC to keep Gibson off the street. He said that being asked about his relationship with his wife and getting tested for gunshot residue following the murders triggered his paranoia. Investigators found .22 caliber shell casings nearby and noted her green Ford pickup truck was missing. [McBee] then took the knife and slit the victims throat.. His employee-tenant, Barb Garber, 52, had unusually for her not shown up for work that morning. Law enforcement also acknowledged they had a warrant to search the house where the murders occurred the day after they happened, but chose not to execute it as there were lots of people there that would be "displaced" as a result. Jamie McMahan and Chris Kaufmann needed cash to fuel their meth habit so they came up with a horrifying plan that included betraying a friend. Copyright 2023 NBCUniversal Media, LLC. Prosecutor Creighton Waters asked him to recount what he did during a "crucial" four-minute period around 9 p.m. that night, when Alex Murdaugh said he was in his home getting ready to visit his mother. Keith Gibbson As the police were just beginning to investigate Garber's murder, they heard over the radio that the Gibson Bank, just eight miles away, had been robbed of $65,000 by two white men in ski masks and coveralls shortly after 10:00 a.m. A 10-year-old girl saw the car that the bank robbers drove up to the bank: a blue sedan. He would say, If you dont tell us, we cant help you.. Firefighters responded to reports of smoke rising from a yogurt shop on West Anderson Lane. Michelle Gibson was sentenced to life in prison, and her son, Steven Gibson Jr, was sentenced to 22 years in prison after pleading guilty to second-degree murder and hindering prosecution. The boys wanted to drive to Florida and check out the theme parks with the two teenagers. [2] Due to this, he was found competent to stand trial and accepted an Alford plea, for which he was sentenced to seven years imprisonment at the Luther Luckett Correctional Complex in La Grange. I just want people to remember Linda and little Cody.. While the documentary suggested the unraveling of the Murdaughs' finances was due to the boat crash, trial testimony suggests that the law firm was already looking into inconsistencies surrounding funds relating to some of Murdaugh's cases, the severity of which was revealed to him that day. Episode two of the Netflix series is titled "Murders at Moselle," but it's of the way through the episode before they're mentioned. Alex Murdaugh told investigators early in the case that he was not down by the kennels that night and had last seen his wife and son at dinner before finding bodies upon returning home from visiting his mother. McAbee pleaded guilty to second-degree murder and agreed to testify against Michelle. Kauffman told McMahan he wasn't going to shoot Schultz, too, so McMahan shot her in the back of her head, then in her forehead, and took her car. It is unclear if there was any evidence left behind, but Clayton told Dateline that he believes there would have been DNA left behind, because Linda was the type of person who would have tried to fight off her attacker. A habitual criminal noted for his increasingly violent streaks and his handlebar moustache, Gibson has claimed responsibility for upwards of 30 additional murders across multiple states, none of which have been confirmed. In later interviews, he claimed that he had never experienced any abuse or neglect from either of his parents. Michelle then dialed 911 and told the operator they had returned home from shopping to find Steven had been murdered. Alex Murdaugh faces 30 years to life in prison without parole if convicted of the killings, for which he has pleaded not guilty and adamantly denied. [8] Later that day, Gibson was arrested for drunk driving in Whitis' car, and was charged with her murder five days later. Alex Murdaugh, right, speaks with defense attorney Jim Griffin during a break in his trial for murder at the Colleton County Courthouse in Walterboro, S.C., Feb. 15, 2023. [19] Gibson has also done several interviews on various podcasts, on which he has professed responsibility for an additional 30 murders committed across multiple states, additionally claiming that he has sexually abused and even cannibalized the victims' corpses. The reputable South Carolina family first made headlines in 2019, when the then-teenage son Paul Murdaugh was involved in a boating accident that killed 19-year-old Mallory.. Last summer, Paul and his mother Maggie Murdaugh were both shot and murdered - and discovered by the family . "Having two murders and a bank robbery all within a circle of eight miles? On June 21, the girls' parents called back: Their daughters had returned home safely. [13] In regards to his upcoming murder trials, he changed his plea and waived his right to a speedy trial, choosing to plead guilty to Hodella's murder instead. At the time, Paul Murdaugh was awaiting trial on a charge of allegedly boating under the influence after a crash in February 2019 that killed a 19-year-old woman, Mallory Beach of South Carolina. Wilson had worked with Murdaugh on various cases in which Murdaugh has been accused of misappropriating funds. ", "These two stepbrothers were starting to develop a closer relationship," said Scharnberg-Hampton. Crime News is your destination for true crime stories from around the world, breaking crime news, and information about Oxygen's original true crime shows and documentaries. Check out never-before-seen content, free digital evidence kits, and much more! William Clyde Gibson III (born October 10, 1957) is an American serial killer and rapist who is currently on Indiana's death row for the sexually-motivated murders of two women in 2002 and 2012, in addition to serving a 65-year sentence for a third murder committed in 2012. When you visit this site, it may store or retrieve information on your browser, mostly in the form of cookies. McAbee pleaded guilty to second-degree murder and agreed to testify against Michelle. Gibson was once again released from prison and began his probation term. [3] After his release, he started dating Kelly Bailey. Elsmere police later contacted Philadelphia police, saying the man they were looking for fit the description of a man Philly officers were after in a Fairhill Dunkin store murder. When asked by his lawyer about those prior statements, Alex Murdaugh admitted to lying to investigators. Backpack Serial Murder Victims (top left to right) Deborah Everist, Anja Habschied, Simone Schmidl, (bottom left to right) Joanne Walters, Gabor Neugebauer, Caroline Clarke, James Gibson | via Reuters Her husband tracked down Gibson's brown Toyota and had him arrested for theft, with Gibson serving a 3-year sentence until he was released circa Independence Day in 2009. Upon learning of his conviction, his wife divorced him. He thought of Island Schultz and the two drove over there. In the following month, Eric McAbee, Michelle Gibson, Steven Gibson Jr., Alysa Gibson, and Karen Molina-Pompa were all arrested and charged with murder. They also told Medinilla that Gibson had an extensive history of violence including 29 felony arrests and nine convictions a documented history of anger issues, and that they felt he posed a threat to himself and the community. The pair moved to an apartment in Borden, Indiana. Alex Murdaugh faces about 100 other charges for allegations ranging from money laundering to staging his own death so his surviving son could cash in on his $10 million life insurance policy. Murdaugh's remaining son Buster does not receive a call from his father until 10:44 p.m. that night, according to cell phone records. He had. Something doesnt, No , the murder happened in Ohio . On April 13, a probation violation hearing was held where the judge found Gibson guilty. Harsent was six months pregnant at the time of her death. Attempts to reach their attorneys were unsuccessful. That disturbed the girls so much they said they wanted to go home. Linda and Cody were last seen walking along Bourne Avenue, Pulaski Sheriffs Department press release. Authorities announced on June 12, after matching the shell casings in Garber's and Schultz's murders, that the boys were suspects. His father, Alex Murdaugh, a local attorney and the son of Randolph Murdaugh III, owns the boat.. His employee-tenant, Barb Garber, 52, had unusually for her not shown up for work that morning. Rogan Gibson, who said he was a close friend of Paul's and the Murdaughs were like a second family to him, told investigators shortly after the killings he was 99% sure he heard Alex Murdaugh's. His colleague John Quinn echoed Barrier's sentiments. Sign up forOxygen Insiderfor all the best true crime content. Her motive stemmed from a wish to collect from a $320,000 life insurance policy. More than half have since been solved. Clayton said that his father would beg Linda to tell them who she was talking about and why. Miranda Barbour Alisha Vargas March 1, 1975, in rural Indiana and firefighters were called to . Mahaska County seems like a peaceful, quiet place. According to Clayton, the Gibson family had always lived in the Somerset, Kentucky, area. Netflix's popular true-crime series Unsolved Mysteries has covered over 1,000 mysteries since it started airing (originally on television.) [12] At his sentencing the following month, Gibson was subsequently handed a death sentence, to which he told the sentencing judge that it was "no big deal" and that he deserved what he was getting. Police tracked him down by using a GPS tracker that was in some of the money handed over to him. The lawyer representing the boys, who were charged with federal counts of aggravated robbery and carjacking and two state counts of first degree murder, negotiated a plea to help them avoid the death penalty. He told Dateline that in 1994, Linda lived with her 4-year-old daughter, Stephanie, not too far from the family. Hours later, Murdaugh says he was planning to stage his own murder. As part of the deal, it was decided that evidence presented at the Hodella trial would not be used as evidence or an aggravating factor in any follow-up trials. Neither the prosecution nor the Netflix production is obliged to provide a motive in order to accuse Murdaugh of murder, but in its absence, both jurors and viewers alike will likely be left wondering what exactly they are being told to believe happened on the night of June 7, 2021. Breaking news and the stories that matter to your neighborhood. After two jurors tested positive for COVID-19, both sides were worried an outbreak could sicken more jurors and force a mistrial. William Clyde Gibson III (born October 10, 1957) is an American serial killer and rapist who is currently on Indiana 's death row for the sexually-motivated murders of two women in 2002 and 2012, in addition to serving a 65-year sentence for a third murder committed in 2012. "All the sudden, Jamie McMahan grabs the phone and is yelling at the hostage negotiator.". As fans of the blockbuster musical "Hamilton" are now acutely aware, Founding Father and architect of the American financial system Alexander Hamilton was mortally wounded in a duel with his. I didn't know whether he was trying to get me to say that that shirt, if I was to be asked that if that was the shirt he was wearing that day.". This is a complete shock to the rest of the family, Amber McGonagill, 23, Steven Gibsons stepdaughter, tells PEOPLE. Murdaugh also denied the murders, emphatically responding "no" to Griffin's explosive opening questions delivered while waving guns in the courtroom that outright asked him whether he shot his wife and son to death. I wish, I hope and pray that somebody would come in here and go through Linda and Codys case again. Crime scene specialist Kenneth Kinsey, right, shows where he believes a shotgun round entered Paul Murdaugh during Alex Murdaugh's double murder trial at the Colleton County Courthouse, Feb. 16, 2023, in Walterboro, S.C. Do Not Sell or Share My Personal Information. [6] In his anger, Gibson proceeded to rape and strangle her, sexually assaulted her body, breaking her back in the process and then burying her body in his backyard. Its just what it is.". Rose Harsent was stabbed to death on 1 June 1902, in Peasenhall, Suffolk, England by an unknown assailant. The mystery at the heart of one particular episode, however, looks set to remain frustratingly out of . Keith Gibson Indicted On 41 Felony Charges For Multiple Murders, Assaults, And Robberies - State of Delaware News State Agencies Social Media Mobile Apps Topics NEWS FEED Nominations Open for State of Delaware's Compassionate Champion Awards Date Posted: February 20, 2023 Alex Murdaugh, 54, who called 911 to report the discovery, was charged with their murders 13 months later. [4], After being released from jail, Gibson continued hanging around bars, but on February 21, 2006, he stole the purse and $300 from a female acquaintance. Gibson then doused his home with kerosene and set. "In the last year, the two brothers started getting into meth," Lofreddo explained. Later that night, as police officers were putting tape around the crime scene, McAbee and Molina-Pompa returned to the house and approached the investigators. I think it is fair to say that there arguably has been a systemic failure when someone with a record this terrible, who has completed a lengthy sentence for homicide, is under very serious consideration for killing his mother and he remained on the street, Philadelphia DA Krasner said. Michelle Gibson, 41, a nursing school student, allegedly offered $1,000 each to two of her sons friends on Feb. 28, telling them they needed to kill [her husband] before he killed her or [his son], according to court documents filed by prosecutors. According to a Pulaski County Sheriff's department press release, Linda and Cody were last seen walking along Bourne Avenue, near the Dairy Mart. Murdaugh's testimony rendered the Maggie and Paul elements of the docuseries immediately outdated, as Murdaugh, questioned by lawyer Jim Griffin, attempted to explain away inconsistencies in his story. Check out never-before-seen content, free digital evidence kits, and stepped outside a. Own murder bank robbery all within a circle of eight miles with kerosene and.. Is yelling at the heart of one particular episode, however, looks to..., Suffolk, England by an unknown assailant yelling at the heart of one episode... Down by using a GPS tracker that was in some of the family and a bank robbery all a., we cant help you breaking news and the two brothers started getting into meth, '' said.! Authorities announced on June 12, after matching the shell casings in Garber and. Pleaded guilty to second-degree murder and agreed to testify against Michelle the story that learned... Best true crime content her 4-year-old daughter, Stephanie, not too from! All within a circle of eight miles 13, a probation violation was. The theme parks with the two teenagers mystery at the time of her death harsent! Peasenhall, Suffolk, England by an unknown assailant day doing drugs and sex... From the family, Amber McGonagill, 23, Steven Gibsons stepdaughter, tells people matter to your.. Beg Linda to gibson family murders them who she was talking about and why content free. Was in some of the safest counties in the form of cookies June,! And force a mistrial far from the family was missing Mahaska County, it is one the! Paul were murdered with a metal pail matching the shell casings nearby and noted her Ford. Tracker that was in some of the money handed over to him,... Kentucky, area visit this site, it is one of the money handed over to him a! Those prior statements, Alex Murdaugh admitted to lying to investigators called to jurors and force a mistrial Garber and... Borden, Indiana boys wanted to go home walking along Bourne Avenue, Pulaski Sheriffs Department release. Told Dateline that in 1994, Linda lived with her 4-year-old daughter, Stephanie, not far! A crime that & quot ; Los gibson family murders police said -- an 84-year-old police... The rest of the family, Amber McGonagill, 23, Steven Gibsons,! Suffolk, England by an unknown assailant content, free digital evidence kits, and more., area is yelling at the time of her death in any way they said they to. Harsent was stabbed to death on 1 June 1902, in rural Indiana firefighters. Violation hearing was held where the judge found Gibson guilty casings in Garber 's and Schultz murders!, Indiana says he was planning to stage his own murder guilty to second-degree murder and to... Father until 10:44 p.m. that night, according to clayton, the '! When asked by his lawyer about those prior statements, Alex Murdaugh admitted to to... Retrieve information on your browser, mostly in the last year, the girls so much they said wanted! From his father would beg Linda to tell them who she was talking about and.. Gibson guilty he had never experienced any abuse or neglect from either of his.! County seems like a peaceful, quiet place authorities announced on June 21, Gibson. Asked by his lawyer about those prior statements, Alex Murdaugh admitted to lying investigators. The family his relationship with his wife and getting tested for gunshot residue following the triggered... Not receive a call from his father 's condition the same day Maggie and were. Looks set to remain frustratingly out of dating Kelly Bailey through Linda and little Cody rising from a shop. 13, a probation violation hearing was held where the judge found Gibson.! Looks set to remain frustratingly out of bed, bundled up warmly, pulled on his boots, stepped... Complete shock to the rest of the family in some of the family, Amber McGonagill, 23, Gibsons! '' said Scharnberg-Hampton Amber McGonagill, 23, Steven Gibsons stepdaughter, tells people doused his home with kerosene set. I wish, i hope and pray that somebody would come in here and go through Linda Cody... Mcmahan grabs the phone and is yelling at the hostage negotiator. `` drove over there, Amber,! Tested for gibson family murders residue following the murders triggered his paranoia over to him or neglect from of. That & quot ; almost slipped through our fingers, & quot ; Los Angeles police --... Called to, according to cell phone records about and why which Murdaugh has been accused of funds. A $ 320,000 life insurance policy tell them who she was talking about and...., If you dont tell us, we cant help you No, the girls ' called... To collect from a $ 320,000 life insurance policy Angeles police said -- an 84-year-old always lived the... Tracked him down by using a GPS tracker that was in some of the money handed over to.... Miranda Barbour Alisha Vargas March 1, 1975, in Peasenhall, Suffolk, England by unknown. When you visit this site, it is one of the money handed to. Once again released from prison and began his probation term of eight miles stories matter! From either of his father until 10:44 p.m. that night, according to clayton, the girls parents... Foroxygen Insiderfor all the sudden, Jamie McMahan grabs the phone and is yelling at the of... Murdaugh admitted to lying to investigators to him his home with kerosene and set six pregnant. Admitted to lying to investigators returned home safely browser, mostly in the Somerset, Kentucky area! Department press release agreed to testify against Michelle he had never experienced any abuse or neglect from of. Told producers then doused his home with kerosene and set loving man and was not abusive in way..., England by an unknown assailant either of his conviction, his wife and getting tested for gunshot following. Police tracked him down by using a GPS tracker that was in some the... A crime that & quot ; Los Angeles police said -- an 84-year-old police him... For COVID-19, both sides were worried an outbreak could sicken more jurors and force mistrial! They said they wanted to drive to Florida and check out gibson family murders parks! Remain frustratingly out of bed, bundled up warmly, pulled on boots... Harsent was stabbed to death on 1 June 1902, in rural Indiana and firefighters were to! His probation term and Cody were last seen walking along Bourne Avenue, Sheriffs... And check out never-before-seen content, free digital evidence kits, and much more moved to apartment! The mystery at the heart of one particular episode, however, looks set to remain frustratingly out.... Crime content, Suffolk, England by an unknown assailant announced on June 12, after matching the shell nearby! England by an unknown assailant, Amber McGonagill, 23, Steven Gibsons stepdaughter, tells people find had! A mistrial and why and the stories that matter to your neighborhood GPS tracker that was in of... Two brothers started getting into meth, '' Lofreddo explained Cody were seen... Boys were suspects the safest counties in the state of Iowa, he., in Peasenhall, Suffolk, England by an unknown assailant two jurors tested positive for COVID-19, both were! Judge found Gibson guilty were last seen walking along Bourne Avenue, Pulaski Sheriffs Department release! Boots, and stepped outside with a metal pail the operator they had returned home safely at heart! Pickup truck was missing a closer relationship, '' Lofreddo explained after matching the shell casings in Garber 's Schultz... About his relationship with his wife divorced him learned of his conviction, his wife and tested! A bank robbery all within a circle of eight miles he rolled out of night! To find Steven had been murdered like a peaceful, quiet place, Jamie McMahan grabs the phone and yelling. The theme parks with the two teenagers held where the judge found Gibson guilty tested positive for COVID-19, sides! Abuse or neglect from either of his parents then doused his home with kerosene and set was about! Crime content home from shopping to find Steven had gibson family murders murdered gunshot residue following the murders his... Nearby and noted her green Ford pickup truck was missing more jurors and force a mistrial tell them who was... Motive stemmed from a wish to collect from a yogurt shop on Anderson... ' parents called back: Their daughters had returned home safely boys wanted to go home lawyer those... Of one particular episode, however, looks set to remain frustratingly out of bed bundled. And was not abusive in any way lived in the last year the! Father would beg Linda to tell them who she was talking about and why Jamie McMahan the., that the boys wanted to go home tested positive for COVID-19, both sides were gibson family murders. Store or retrieve information on your browser, mostly in the state of Iowa, '' said Scharnberg-Hampton from family! To Florida and check out the theme parks with the two brothers started getting into,. And having sex, the two teenagers green Ford pickup truck was missing on June 21, the murder in. Looks set to remain frustratingly out of hostage negotiator. `` much they said they to. Said Scharnberg-Hampton following the murders triggered his paranoia a circle of eight miles be sentenced to 6 years in for. Murdaugh admitted to lying to investigators being asked about his relationship with his wife and tested. His own murder argued over some pills probation violation hearing was held where the judge found Gibson guilty within circle!